Dystopian Novels Where Miscarriage Is a Crime (and the Real Cases Behind Them)

Dystopian Novels Where Miscarriage Is a Crime (and the Real Cases Behind Them)

Written By Kelly K. Branyik

Kelly is a lifelong writer and author. She avidly writes for Elephant Journal and pilots a travel blog. Kelly runs solely on tea, burritos, and books.
November 18, 2026

4 mins read

5 views

*Disclaimer: Articles hosted on Kelly Branyik’s website may include affiliate links.

If you’re looking for dystopian novels where miscarriage or pregnancy is treated as a crime, start with Unborn by Rachel McLean, The Age of the Child by Kristen J. Tsetsi, and Future Home of the Living God by Louise Erdrich. The Handmaid’s Tale is the classic that started it all, and my own novel, Shadows in Dream Stone, is set in a world where losing a pregnancy can send you to prison. Here are eight books, plus what the real numbers say.

Why I Wrote a Dystopia Where Miscarriage Is a Crime

I wrote Shadows in Dream Stone because I was furious. I started writing it after Texas’s 2021 abortion law took effect, and then Roe v. Wade fell the next year. Women were losing their reproductive rights in real time, and I wanted a hero.

So I dreamed up Abaddon Ordell, a Byronic hero who does something bad for the sake of good. The road that gets her there is bleak, dark, and hard. It’s also a road real people are walking right now. I made sure there was hope and love along the way, because there always is, even in the worst places.

Is Miscarriage a Crime in Real Life?

Miscarriage itself isn’t written into U.S. law as a crime. But people are still prosecuted after pregnancy losses under other laws, like abuse of a corpse, concealing a birth, or child neglect.

  • The numbers are rising. In the first three years after Dobbs (June 2022 to June 2025), prosecutors brought at least 902 pregnancy-related criminal cases across 23 states. Seventy of them involved a pregnancy loss or the death of a newborn, according to Pregnancy Justice’s October 2026 report.
  • Old laws are being used in new ways. Pregnancy Justice’s January 2026 report, After Pregnancy Loss, found 18 states that criminalize not reporting pregnancy loss remains. It also found 19 states that criminalize how remains are disposed of, or classify it as “abuse of a corpse.”
  • Only one state has explicitly repealed these laws. Washington’s Dignity in Pregnancy Loss Act of 2025 is the only state law so far that explicitly removes legal provisions criminalizing pregnancy loss.

That’s why these novels don’t read like far-off fiction anymore.

Dystopian Novels Where Pregnancy Is Policed or Punished

The Handmaid’s Tale by Margaret Atwood (1985)

In The Handmaid’s Tale, a theocracy called Gilead has replaced the United States, and fertile women are assigned as Handmaids to bear children for powerful men. Offred, the narrator, remembers the life she had before and tries to survive the one she has now. Every book on this list owes it something.

Read it if: you somehow haven’t yet. Start here.

Unborn by Rachel McLean (2020)

In Unborn, it’s America in 2026, abortion has been criminalized, and three women end up in prison for very different reasons. One of them, Grace, had a natural miscarriage that the state decided was an abortion. Rachel McLean combines a dystopia with a legal thriller as the women fight the system together.

Read it if: you want the book closest to the question “what if miscarriage were a crime?”

The Age of the Child by Kristen J. Tsetsi

In The Age of the Child, Roe v. Wade has been repealed, contraception and abortion are outlawed, and even miscarriages are suspect and investigated. Kristen J. Tsetsi follows the consequences from one generation to the next, and that turn surprises you.

Read it if: you want a book club pick that will start arguments in the best way.

Shadows in Dream Stone by Kelly K. Branyik (2026) (my book)

In Shadows in Dream Stone, a miscarriage is a crime. Abaddon Ordell, a teacher, fighter, sister, and wife, is sentenced to nine years in the brutal Dream Stone prison after losing her child. Inside, she finds allies, a slow-burn sapphic romance, and a plan to bring down the regime that put her there.

Read it if: you want feminist rage, a Byronic heroine, and a love story that survives in the dark. Read more about Shadows in Dream Stone.

When She Woke by Hillary Jordan (2011)

In When She Woke, convicted criminals have their skin dyed to match their crime. Hannah Payne wakes up red because she had an abortion, and she refuses to name the father. Hillary Jordan writes it as a dystopian retelling of The Scarlet Letter.

Read it if: you want to see how public shame becomes a policy.

Red Clocks by Leni Zumas (2018)

In Red Clocks, abortion is illegal again in the United States, and in vitro fertilization is banned. Leni Zumas follows several women in a small Oregon town, including one who is arrested after helping others end pregnancies.

Read it if: you want the near future, told quietly and close to home.

Future Home of the Living God by Louise Erdrich (2017)

In Future Home of the Living God, evolution appears to be running backward, and a new religious government starts rounding up pregnant women and confining them to prison-like hospitals. Cedar Hawk Songmaker, an Ojibwe woman adopted and raised in Minneapolis, is four months pregnant and goes into hiding. She tells the story as a diary to her unborn child.

Read it if: you want literary fiction with a thriller’s pulse.

The Farm by Joanne Ramos (2019)

In The Farm, Golden Oaks is a luxury retreat in New York’s Hudson Valley where women, many of them immigrants, are paid to carry babies for the ultra-rich. Jane, a Filipina mother, signs up to give her own daughter a better life. Then she learns she can’t leave and is watched around the clock. No one is forced here, and that’s what makes it chilling.

Read it if: you want a dystopia where the control comes with a paycheck.

FAQs: Books Where Miscarriage Is a Crime

Is there a book where miscarriage is a crime?

Yes. In Unborn by Rachel McLean, a woman is imprisoned after the state rules her natural miscarriage an abortion. In Shadows in Dream Stone by Kelly K. Branyik, miscarriage itself is a crime, and the heroine is sentenced to nine years in prison.

Can you go to jail for a miscarriage in the U.S.?

Miscarriage isn’t a crime under U.S. law, but people have been prosecuted after pregnancy losses using other laws. Pregnancy Justice documented 70 cases involving a pregnancy loss or newborn death in the first three years after Dobbs.

What books are like The Handmaid’s Tale but about pregnancy?

Try Future Home of the Living God by Louise Erdrich, Red Clocks by Leni Zumas, and The Farm by Joanne Ramos. Each one is about who controls pregnancy, and why.

Keep Reading

For more books built from real headlines, read 10 Dystopian Novels Based on Real Life, or my list of 8 books like The Handmaid’s Tale. Want first word on the next Dark Stars book? Join my Patreon!

Other Posts You Might Like…